Is Ben Stokes England’s Best Ever Test Captain?

The final moments of the Manchester Test were marred by controversy, with questions raised about England captain Ben Stokes and his team’s conduct during the post-match handshake. While the drama attracted attention, it shouldn't overshadow India’s remarkable resistance across five testing sessions. England’s bowlers had to dig deep, and their visible frustration was understandable. However, it's also important to remember the sportsmanship Stokes and his side showed after India’s heartbreaking defeat at Lord’s, highlighting the fluctuating emotions of a fiercely competitive Test series.

With the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy standing at 2-1 in England’s favour, the hosts are guaranteed not to lose the series. The final Test becomes crucial for India, who must win to level the series. Stokes played a heroic role in Manchester, claiming a five-wicket haul and scoring a vital century. As a player, he continues to cement his legacy as one of England’s greatest match-winners, consistently stepping up in high-pressure moments for his team.

See Also: Playing XI for India and England in ongoing ENG vs IND 5th Test

Since assuming captaincy from Joe Root in 2022, Ben Stokes has sparked a new era in England’s Test cricket. Under his leadership, England have lost just two series, one in India (1-4) and one in Pakistan (1-2). His aggressive style, fearless decisions, and impact-driven leadership have placed him firmly in the conversation among the greatest England Test captains. With continued success, Stokes could well challenge the legacy of past greats like Vaughan, Strauss, and Brearley.

Most successful England captain in Test cricket

Captain	Wins	Matches	W/L Ratio	Win %	Win+Draw %
Joe Root	27	64	1.03	42.18%	50.94%
Michael Vaughan	26	51	2.36	50.98%	70.27%
Andrew Strauss	24	50	2.18	48.00%	68.57%
Alastair Cook	24	59	1.09	40.67%	52.17%
Ben Stokes	22	37	1.69	59.45%	62.85%
Peter May	20	41	2.00	48.78%	66.66%
Mike Brearley	18	31	4.50	58.06%	81.81%

As it can be clearly seen, Joe Root may hold the record for most Test wins as England captain, but his tenure also included one of the most challenging phases in English cricket. Alastair Cook, though credited with a historic series win in India, shares a similar win-loss ratio with Root, reflecting mixed success during his captaincy. Mike Brearley is widely regarded as one of England’s finest leaders, boasting the best win-loss ratio by far, 18 victories to just four defeats. However, it’s worth noting he had the advantage of leading a side that included legends like Ian Botham and Bob Willis, two of England’s all-time greats.

Michael Vaughan and Andrew Strauss also enjoyed impressive captaincy records, but they had the luxury of leading arguably the strongest England teams. In contrast, Ben Stokes has achieved remarkable results with a comparatively less star-studded squad. This ability to inspire and deliver with a weaker side is what perhaps sets Stokes apart from his predecessors.