Cricket News

'None of them are bad guys': David Warner's manager calls for private meeting amid Sandpapergate row

David Warner's manager James Erskine calls for a private meeting to end the Sandpapergate row. Read what he said about Pat Cummins and Cricket Australia's response.

Gopi Marisetty
Published 4 mins read
Former Australia opener David Warner as his manager James Erskine calls for a private players-only meeting amid the Sandpapergate row
Former Australia opener David Warner as his manager James Erskine calls for a private players-only meeting amid the Sandpapergate row

David Warner's manager James Erskine has called for a private meeting between Australian players to end the ongoing Sandpapergate controversy. He believes Pat Cummins, Warner and other players should sit together, discuss their differences and apologise to each other. Erskine also defended the players involved, saying that none of them are bad people despite the disagreement over the 2018 ball-tampering scandal.

The Sandpapergate row has returned to the headlines eight years after the incident in Cape Town. Usman Khawaja, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft have claimed that the Australian team knew about the ball-tampering plan, raising fresh questions about the scandal. However, Cummins, Josh Hazlewood and former Australia coach Darren Lehmann have denied those claims, leading to another public disagreement between the players.

With the controversy continuing, Erskine wants the players to settle the matter themselves rather than involve Cricket Australia (CA) or their managers. Speaking to CODE Sports, he suggested that a face-to-face meeting could help everyone move on from the past. His comments come as Cricket Australia has announced an independent forum to hear from players and staff involved in the 2018 South Africa tour.

Add Us as Your Trusted SourceFollow Cricket Winner on Google to get our coverage first in your feed.
★ Add Cricket Winner

What did James Erskine say? Warner's manager wants Cummins and players to meet without CA

James Erskine believes the Australian players should take responsibility for ending the Sandpapergate row. He said the situation has become difficult because the players continue to disagree about what happened eight years ago. Speaking to CODE Sports, Warner's manager said:

"I think the players have got to sort this out on their own. Right now it is sort of dishonour among cheats, and the fact of the matter is it should be honour among cheats. None of them did the right thing," Erskine said while speaking to CODE Sports.

“But at the end of the day, none of them are bad guys. They are all good guys. I would say the solution is for the Cummins and the Warners and the whole team to get together without managers and without Cricket Australia and they sit in a room and apologise to each other and say that whatever they did, they didn’t do it out of malice or to throw someone under the bus," Erskine added.

Erskine wants the players to speak openly about their problems and leave the meeting without any further arguments. He believes they should accept what happened in the past and stop blaming each other. "They need to have it out among themselves. The deal is after they do that, and some may be upset about things, they leave that room united that that is the end of the situation as far as the players are concerned."

See Also: Josh Hazlewood threatens to boycott 1st Test vs NZ if Pat Cummins loses captaincy

Cricket Australia sets up independent forum, backs Pat Cummins: What happens next?

Cricket Australia has announced an independent forum to hear from players and staff involved in the 2018 South Africa tour. Interim CA chair David Boon and CEO Todd Greenberg said the forum would give everyone a chance to share their side of the story. However, CA has made it clear that the forum will not reopen the original investigation or lead to fresh punishments.

The board has also backed Pat Cummins amid questions about his role in the Sandpapergate scandal. Cameron Bancroft's recent claims have brought more attention to the Australian Test captain, but CA has rejected suggestions that his honesty should be questioned. According to reports, the board wants Cummins to continue leading Australia ahead of the upcoming Test series against New Zealand.

See Also: Watch: "Difficult conversations" – Pat Cummins reveals how Cricket Australia supported him amid ball-tampering allegations

Meanwhile, Fox Sports has temporarily removed David Warner and Usman Khawaja from commentary duties as the controversy continues. The broadcaster said both players would be rested for the next few weeks because of the pressure surrounding the ongoing debate. It remains to be seen whether the Australian players will follow Erskine's suggestion of a private meeting or try to settle their differences through Cricket Australia's independent forum.

Follow us on9M+ fans across platforms

About the Author

Gopi Marisetty
Written By

Gopi Marisetty

author · 2924 articles

A cricket lover who enjoys writing about every match, player, and record. With 1+ year of experience in cricket content writing, I love sharing simple and engaging stories from the game. I focus on match recaps, player insights, and exciting cricket moments, making each article easy to read and enjoyable for every fan.

Watch Now

Web Stories

“

It is not my job to announce the winner

Rohit Sharma on being asked if England were rightly awarded the World Cup title in 2019