'I Wouldn't Pick This Gentleman' - Former England captain criticises Prasidh Krishna after poor show against England in 2nd Test

Prasidh Krishna faced heavy criticism after a poor spell in the 2nd Test, while Mohammed Siraj shone with a six-wicket haul at Edgbaston.

Gopi Marisetty
Gopi Marisetty

2 mins read
Prasidh Krishna
i(x.com/bcci)

Be a winner today!

Get the latest cricket updates, Join our community

iconiconicon

On Day 3 of the series with England, Test 2 at Edgbaston, it was a mixed day for India's bowlers. Mohammed Siraj was great with the ball and claimed his sixth wicket of the innings, while Prasidh Krishna failed to take a wicket and was smashed for 23 runs in a single over by Jamie Smith, including four boundaries and a six. With an economy rate of 5.50, Krishna recorded one of the highest in Test history for bowlers with at least 500 balls.

His poor performance invited criticism from fans and experts. Former England captain Michael Atherton, speaking on commentary, said, "I wouldn't pick this gentleman, Prasidh Krishna.
I would have picked Kuldeep Yadav." Ahead of the match, many had called for Kuldeep’s inclusion, and with Krishna struggling, that decision now looks questionable. A social media post also claimed that Krishna now holds the worst economy rate in Test history, though this has not been officially confirmed.

On the other hand, Mohammed Siraj brought India back into the match with his brilliant bowling. After England’s Harry Brook (158) and Jamie Smith (184*) added 303 runs for the sixth wicket, India needed a breakthrough. Akash Deep bowled Brook, and Siraj cleaned up the lower order with three quick wickets.

Siraj delivers when it matters most

Siraj, speaking to JioHotstar, said, “This feeling is unbelievable. I'd been waiting for a moment like this for over a year. I always bowled well, but wickets didn't come. Today, the morning session felt good, but still no breakthrough—so these six wickets are really special.”

See Also: From IPL heroics to U-19 domination: Vaibhav Suryavanshi smashes 52-ball century against England

Siraj removed Brydon Carse, Josh Tongue, and Shoaib Bashir to complete his six-wicket haul. England were bowled out for 407 after being 84/5, and India ended the day in a strong position. While Siraj and Akash Deep shared all ten wickets, Prasidh Krishna’s place in the team now remains under serious doubt.

Tags:

Follow us on

A cricket lover who enjoys writing about every match, player, and record. With 1+ year of experience in cricket content writing, I love sharing simple and engaging stories from the game. I focus on match recaps, player insights, and exciting cricket moments, making each article easy to read and enjoyable for every fan.
WATCH NOW
Ball boy touching Shubman Gill's feet on the field during India vs Afghanistan Test match — viral moment

12 hrs ago

Watch: Ball boy touches Shubman Gill's feet during IND vs AFG Test — His reaction says it all

Virat Kohli and Bhuvneshwar Kumar performing the Kikli dance during RCB's IPL 2026 title celebration — viral video moment

4 days ago

Watch: Virat Kohli and Bhuvneshwar Kumar do 'Kikli' dance after IPL 2026 title win —Viral video

Krunal Pandya showing five fingers five trophies gesture with Virat Kohli reacting hilariously during RCB IPL 2026 Final celebration

5 days ago

Watch: Krunal Pandya's savage '5 trophies' gesture sparks hilarious reaction from Virat Kohli after RCB win IPL 2026 Final

CRICKET STORIES

It is not my job to announce the winner

Rohit Sharma on being asked if England were rightly awarded the World Cup title in 2019